Skip to content

Merge Records: A Starter Guide to 10 Essential Albums

From a bedroom in Chapel Hill to one of indie music's great labels. A short history of Merge Records and 10 essential albums, from Superchunk to Waxahatchee.

By unknowndivide staff 4 min read
Album covers for Neutral Milk Hotel's In the Aeroplane Over the Sea, The Magnetic Fields' 69 Love Songs and Destroyer's Kaputt
Neutral Milk Hotel, In the Aeroplane Over the Sea; The Magnetic Fields, 69 Love Songs; Destroyer, Kaputt. Artwork via Merge Records

Merge Records began as a way for two friends to put out their own band's music, and it has been releasing records ever since. Its catalog runs from scrappy indie rock to home recordings, chamber pop, Americana and electronic music.

Here is a short history of Merge and 10 essential albums to start with. Every album description below draws on the label's own notes for that record.

A short history

According to the label, Merge Records was started in the summer of 1989 by Laura Ballance and Mac McCaughan, the same summer they formed the band Superchunk in Chapel Hill, North Carolina. The first releases were cassettes by Wwax and Bricks, followed by the first Superchunk 7-inch single, back when the band was known simply as Chunk. For the first three years, the 7-inch single was the format of choice, with cash borrowed from friends to fund each project.

Various bedrooms served as Merge headquarters until 1992, when the label put out its first full-length release, Superchunk's Tossing Seeds, on CD, LP and cassette. Merge moved between offices until 2001, when it settled into its own building in downtown Durham, North Carolina. The label celebrated its 35th birthday in 2024.

As the label puts it, the roster has changed and expanded over the years, but what it looks for in records, as fans, is still there in the music it releases.

10 essential Merge albums

1. Superchunk, Foolish

Start with the band that started it all. Merge describes Foolish as Superchunk's fourth full-length album and its first full-length for Merge. The band recorded it with Brian Paulson in Minneapolis, and Paulson mixed it with the band at Steve Albini's home studio in Chicago. The label's notes call it a blast of songwriting growth that kept the band's trademark energy, with the guitars of Jim Wilbur and Mac McCaughan front and center.

2. Neutral Milk Hotel, In the Aeroplane Over the Sea

Merge describes In the Aeroplane Over the Sea as a record that moves between Jeff Mangum's powerful solo acoustic work and full horn-section marches, touching on history, religion and sex along the way. The label also sells a t-shirt inspired by the album's artwork.

3. The Magnetic Fields, 69 Love Songs

Stephin Merritt's 69 Love Songs is, in the label's words, a boxed set rumination on love: funny, smart, dark and a lifetime's worth of listening. Merge also sells it as three separate volumes, and it reissued the album's companion t-shirt in 2019 for the record's 20th anniversary.

4. The Mountain Goats, All Hail West Texas

Merge calls All Hail West Texas the peak of the Mountain Goats' home recording era. John Darnielle recorded the songs on the condenser mic of a Panasonic boombox, with no overdubbing, usually within minutes of writing them. The Merge edition was remastered from the original reels and adds 7 unearthed songs from two surviving cassettes. Highlights include "Jenny" and "The Best Ever Death Metal Band in Denton."

5. She & Him, Volume 3

She & Him are Zooey Deschanel and M. Ward. According to Merge, Volume 3, released on May 7, 2013, was their third album of original material, with 14 songs: 11 Deschanel originals and 3 covers. Deschanel wrote it during downtime while filming New Girl, and M. Ward produced it. The label describes tempo shifts, disco grooves, strings and horn flourishes.

6. Lambchop, Nixon

Released in early 2000, Nixon was Lambchop's fifth LP. Merge describes the Nashville group gliding from one unexpected grace note to the next, weaving funk, R&B, gospel, country and vintage folk together, starting with the swell of horns in the middle of opener "The Old Gold Shoe." The reissue adds a bonus disc, White Sessions 1998: How I Met Cat Power.

7. Caribou, Swim

Merge is not only a guitar label. Dan Snaith, the mathematics scholar and multi-instrumentalist behind Caribou, followed his Polaris Music Prize-winning album Andorra with Swim, which the label describes as a more complex, many-layered record full of fascinating rhythms, instruments and voices, including those of Luke Lalonde on "Jamelia."

8. Destroyer, Kaputt

Dan Bejar's Destroyer has been an ever-evolving project, and Merge presents Kaputt as its latest chapter at the time, highlighting the song "Bay of Pigs" and lyrics that ruminate on American communism and the pointlessness of writing songs.

9. Camera Obscura, Look to the East, Look to the West

According to Merge, Look to the East, Look to the West is Camera Obscura's first album in more than 10 years. Tracyanne Campbell's band reunited with producer Jari Haapalainen, who also worked on Let's Get Out of This Country and My Maudlin Career. Merge's roster is full of kindred pop spirits, including Teenage Fanclub, whose recent Merge release we covered.

10. Waxahatchee, Saint Cloud

Merge describes Katie Crutchfield's Saint Cloud as stripping back the big guitars of her previous Waxahatchee records, Out in the Storm and Ivy Tripp, to make space for her voice and lyrics. The label calls the result a classic Americana sound with modern touches.

Where to go next

Once you have these, dig into Superchunk's early singles on Tossing Seeds: Singles 1989-91 to hear where the label began. Merge's official store carries its catalog across formats.

If you like label deep dives, our guides to Sub Pop Records and 4AD are the natural next stops. New to vinyl? Start with our best turntables for beginners.

More records and reissues live in our vinyl hub.